Skip to main content

State Significant Development

Response to Submissions

Paling Yards Wind Farm

Oberon

Current Status: Response to Submissions

Interact with the stages for their names

  1. SEARs
  2. Prepare EIS
  3. Exhibition
  4. Collate Submissions
  5. Response to Submissions
  6. Assessment
  7. Recommendation
  8. Determination

Development of a wind farm with up to 47 wind turbines and associated infrastructure.

Attachments & Resources

Notice of Exhibition (1)

Request for SEARs (16)

SEARs (1)

EIS (32)

Response to Submissions (1)

Agency Advice (14)

Submissions

Filters
Showing 121 - 140 of 458 submissions
David Carpenter
Object
OBERON , New South Wales
Message
Attachments
Can Chn Tu
Object
Oberon , New South Wales
Message
See attached
Attachments
Una Gearon
Object
OBERON , New South Wales
Message
See attached
Attachments
Beatrice Cannizzaro
Object
OBERON , New South Wales
Message
Attachments
Christine Cameron-Jones
Object
DUCKMALOI , New South Wales
Message
Attachments
Matthew Butler
Object
ST MARYS , New South Wales
Message
Attachments
Peter Burt
Object
MOSS VALE , New South Wales
Message
Attachments
Frank Van Bergen
Object
WILTON , New South Wales
Message
See attached
Attachments
Rose Van Bergen
Object
WILTON , New South Wales
Message
See attached
Attachments
Katarina Varga
Object
BLACK SPRINGS , New South Wales
Message
See attached
Attachments
Matthew Wade
Object
DUCKMALOI , New South Wales
Message
See attached
Attachments
Name Withheld
Object
GUYRA , New South Wales
Message
I Vehemently Object to the Oberon area proposal for a Wind Farm, being Paling Yards Wind Farm.
“All non-project involved receptors were found to be below the relevant noise criteria. Some project involved receptors are predicted to slightly exceed the WHO noise criteria, however, these locations are used for a very limited part of the year only and it is proposed to enter into a noise agreement regulating their use and that these will not be used should post construction noise testing definitively show an exceedance of the criteria. “
Who is responsible for the Statement above. Who gets paid to offer lines inappropriate, Incorrect- lines of unable information, yes. You will Never enforce Anything, gov.au, and you won’t. You will be Responsible for this particular statement, gov.au. It will be The Statement that will be under investigation and This is The Particular Statement you Cannot ever Ever Ever Ever Monitor.
Ban Wind Farms Right Now, those with 3 Blades and infrastructure that harms Continents, yes.
Ban 3-Bladed Wind farms. Use Bladeless Wind Turbines, put them along Roads, under Power Lines, yes. Save a Lotta Money, gov.au. Won’t Harm Farmland we Need to Grow our Food for the Next 4 to 8 Generations from Now, 18 yrs of age, Now.
I Demand this. I Demand that Renewables On Farmland, On Country, In Wilderness, In Oceans, be Banned Immediately.
Use Bladeless Wind Turbines along roadsides, and On Rooftops, yeah, there, right Near Power Lines, Highways, yeah, then we won’t need 3-Bladed infrastructure Harming any Farmland or any Wilderness, or any Oceans.
“Noise predictions were made for receptors within a 6 km of a proposed WTG. WTG noise has been predicted using an indicative layout of 59 WTG’s and an assumed mix of 3 turbine types and assessed against relevant criteria prescribed by the SA EPA Guideline and World Health Organisation (WHO) goals where appropriate.”
Union Fenosa Wind Australia Pty Ltd
Paling Yards Wind Farm
Noise Impact Assessment
Report Number 640.10127-R1
20 November 2012 - NOTE 2012, 2012
Revision 3
Page 15
SLR Consulting Australia Pty Ltd
4.6 Construction Noise Guidelines.
What Rubbish. What Rot. Place the company who wrote this Under Investigation for the reason being Irresponsible. You in government are Needing to Be Investigated for allowing this utter Rubbish.
The Amenity Criteria (LAeq level) for the residential noise sensitive locations for the Paling Yards Wind
Farm project are,
Day Period 50 dBA
Evening Period 45 dBA
Night Period 40 dBA
If it’s a Rural Area then Why are the dBA’s Higher during Work hours ? How Dare You Office workers subject your fellow Australians to higher dBA’s while they Work hard, growing Your Food. Safe Level is 8dBA. 8DBA. A Safe Level.
I Demand Change in Guidelines to Protect Aussies from Infrasound as a 80-20-80-20-80-20-80-20-80-40-80etctecetc dBA level, 24/7, day or night.
I Demand a Royal Commission into gov.au, and this company, and personnel allowing this type of what, research ? It isn’t research. It is Not. Is Not. When you are Listening to a Sound and it Is there isn’t there is there is there is there isn’t there is there isn’t there etc etc etc, it is Not possible to determine Anything. How Dare You allow this rubbish. It is Rubbish. You place our People under Hideous Conditions and Never Ever Ever Ever do you Ever Monitor Afterward. You all need to be in prison, gov.au. You Have No Right to Force Renewables Onto Prime Agricultural Land in a Dry Continent, and it is Force you see, gov.au, when neighbours Are the ones At Home, At Work , on their farms Every day Every night and yet Not one of them gets heard , do they, gov, eh.
Many suffer. You Don’t care, and Never will. I Do Care for these people you threaten with Renewables On Country, when WT's Can be Bladeless, On Our Rooftops, Along Roads, under existing Powerlines, yes. You have NO Right to ever Force neighbours to live next to Wind farms. You have No Right to Harm others, including the places people live and work in. You are Unwell, gov.au. Unwell.
You have No Right to force farmers to live near These Things, called Wind Farms On Farmland, On Country.
In a word, Shame on you, gov.au. Shame on you, the people working for government in your office Not near Wind Farms are you?
Go away from Precious Oberon Region please, gov.au. You are quite Unaware this Area that Waters my Area, yes. Oberon is a Cool Climate region. Do Not Ever Ever Ever put 3 Bladed Wind Turbines on these Areas. They can Drought areas you see. It did happen in ours. I need Renewables under Investigation for Impacts to Climate, Correct, Impacts to Climate.
I need you in a Inquiry, Australian Government. And Immediately.
You don’t know how this island named Australia by Englishmen even waters itself, and that is Correct.
One day it will be a Dry Continent indeed. It is. Government still hasn’t noticed, eh, government, all departments, Without a care for Country or anything upon it, as Life.
Go Away from Oberon Right Now. Cease and Desist Paling Yards WF.
Prime Agricultural land it is, yes.
One day all our Food will come from OS. It will be the fault of our government, Unaware Australia Is a Dry Continent. WFs Harm Our Dry Continent.
OK. Oberon. Sacred Land oh Yes. Up through to our region in Northern Tablelands NSW. NT receives Rain from Oberon, Correct. If you put High Towers of 3-Blades upon the Tablelands in Oberon then we don’t receive the rain from Victoria.
Work it out. I need a Complete Report on Cloud Cover coming from Victoria to Northern Tablelands, Also under Threat, at this time, from Renewables.
Get Off Oberon. Get Off My Nation Immediately, gov.au, Without Awareness of How this Nation Waters this Land, in a Drought Again.
I’ll tell you, me, a Researcher of Human Impacts To :
Vital Upper Tributary Catchments on the Top of the Range of the Drainage Divide of the Great Divide of the NT's to the Oberon to the Murray River to the Victorian Grampians, to the Outer area of Mortlake, under Threat already.
Go Away please from My Nation, please, gov.au. you Do Not know Anything about. Nothing. Absolutely Nothing. You Don’t care for this Dry Continent. I cannot let you govern it.
I Demand a Royal Commission into Renewables that are A Waste Of These Things, coming from Sacred Lands, yes.
Rock. From Sacred Land, Yes.
Minerals, from where, and I Need A Reply as to From Where in my Email by 1 Week’s time.
I Demand a Immediate Cessation of renewable projects. I need renewables under investigation by a Royal Commission, Immediately. I Mean it.
God Help this Nation, a Dry Continent. Get It. You Never Will. I Cannot allow this government to be in a position of Control of Prime Agricultural Land in Need of Protection from Government, Unaware there are another 8 Generations to come. Needing Farmland, and Where will it be?
God. Stop them, gov.au, for they know Not what they do to a Dry Continent, they do Not understand.
I Demand a Royal Commission into the Idea named Climate Change, ruining this Planet, Yes it Is. How Dare you Comply with the European American control freaks, who want to Make Money, and that is All they want, it is.
One day I Need the government admitting it was Wrong about Renewables. I need that day to be today, 10th November 2023, yes.
One day it will be very much a different world when we All work out we don’t need more electricity, but more Care. Care. Care. Care to the All, Care to the All, Care to the All On Country, a Dry Continent, unlike Any other. I Pray for Rain every single day. It’s my Job. I have to. This poor Nation is So abused I cannot bear it.
It is Abused. It is Drained. It is Poisoned. It is Mined for No reason but Money. It is a Dry Continent. It is Dry. It is bare of Trees. It Is. Past 800 years saw a decrease in Forests, Original. In the past 148 years, Forest Loss is Threatening Rainfall. Rainfall. Yet Renewables can Enter Wilderness and Prime Agricultural Land. How Dare Australian Government abuse this Nation not theirs.
What Are you Doing to this Nation, but Harming it, you Are, gov.au, all depts.
Bladeless Wind Farms can be beside the road, under power lines, On Rooftops, using Bladeless Technology. Our Farmland can then be free of Renewables.
You have No Idea what you are Doing, gov.au.
I Demand a Immediate Moratorium on Renewables, and Transmission Lines since the implementation of 500 kv voltage Transmission Lines. I need the Research that has been undertaken by gov.au, on 500 kv Transmission Lines please. Thank you. Right. Blades are Made from What? Tell me. I need that information in a week’s time, I do. Where does Every Single component of a Blade for a Wind Turbine come from. If it has Balsa Wood in it, I will take you to Court for Harm and Loss to:
Amazon Forests.- Indigeneous in the Ecuadorian Amazon, or Amazon.- The Ecuadorian Amazon and Amazon actually function the El Nino cycles, El Nino.- The Loss of Culture in the Amazon region of South America.- The Loss of food resources of Amazon creation. Hideous companies are Bribing local indigenous with Money which completely destroys Culture of Indigenous, forced to take money because their Natural Resources have been basically stolen, Yes.
Ban 3-Bladed Wind Farms Right Now.
Infrasound. You forgot about it. I haven’t. I know what it is. You do not. I do. You Should Know what it is if you had done your research on current Wind Farms on the Ridgetops of Tablelands in NSW. Infrasound, a Harm and Loss To Sound to the Land as a Field Form Phenomena of Sacred ley Lines that cross wherever Catchments enter the lower river levels, which are 8 metres Lower than 800 years ago. The Vital nature of Ley Lines to this Nation of Sacredness to Southern Hemisphere Continents is this:
Rivers are Ley Lines. They are. They bring the Octave Harmonics through the Land. The Land is a Sound itself. A Sound Itself. It has a Octave Harmonic Sound Wave through it. Octave Sound is a Phenomena of Eon evolution Time 3-BladedWind Turbines alter.
Gail Watson
Object
SHOOTERS HILL , New South Wales
Message
See attached
Attachments
Stephen White
Object
Duckmaloi , New South Wales
Message
See attached
Attachments
Katie Brown
Object
RABY , New South Wales
Message
Attachments
Bow O'Connell
Comment
EDITH , New South Wales
Message
Attachments
Allan Williams
Object
OBERON , New South Wales
Message
See attached
Attachments
Craig Beveridge
Object
HASSALL GROVE , New South Wales
Message
Attachments
Robyn Wiseman
Object
OBERON , New South Wales
Message
See attached
Attachments
Beth Kornman
Object
TARANA , New South Wales
Message
Attachments

Pagination

Project Details

Application Number
SSD-29064077
Assessment Type
State Significant Development
Development Type
Electricity Generation - Wind
Local Government Areas
Oberon

Contact Planner

Name
Kurtis Wathen