Skip to main content

State Significant Development

Determination

Narrabri Gas

Narrabri Shire

Current Status: Determination

Interact with the stages for their names

  1. SEARs
  2. Prepare EIS
  3. Exhibition
  4. Collate Submissions
  5. Response to Submissions
  6. Assessment
  7. Recommendation
  8. Determination

The project involves the progressive development of a coal seam gas field over 20 years with up to 850 gas wells and ancillary infrastructure, including gas processing and water treatment facilities.

Attachments & Resources

SEARs (3)

SEARs
SEARs - Attachment 2A
SEARs - Attachment 3A

EIS (71)

Development Application
Site Verification Certificate
Chapter 01 Introduction
Chapter 02 Location and setting
Chapter 03 Strategic context and need
Chapter 04 State legislation and approvals
Chapter 05 Commonwealth requirements
Chapter 06 Project description
Chapter 07 Produced water management
Chapter 08 Assessment of alternatives
Chapter 09 Community and stakeholder consultation
Chapter 10 Approach to the impact assessment
Chapter 11 Groundwater and geology
Chapter 12 Surface water quality
Chapter 13 Hydrology and geomorphology
Chapter 14 Soils and land contamination
Chapter 15 Terrestrial ecology
Chapter 16 Aquatic ecology
Chapter 17 Property and land use
Chapter 18 Air quality
Chapter 19 Noise and vibration
Chapter 20 Aboriginal heritage
Chapter 21 Historic heritage
Chapter 22 Traffic and transport
Chapter 23 Landscape and visual
Chapter 24 Greenhouse gas
Chapter 25 Hazard and risk
Chapter 26 Social and health
Chapter 27 Economics
Chapter 28 Waste management
Chapter 29 Cumulative impact
Chapter 30 Environmental management and monitoring
Chapter 31 Project commitments
Chapter 32 Justification and conclusion
Chapter 33 References
Chapter 34 Terms and abbreviations
Appendix A - Environmental assessment requirements
Appendix B - Referral of proposed action
Appendix C - Field Development Protocol
Appendix D - Stakeholder and community consultation report
Appendix E - Drilling waste letter from NSW Environment Prote
Appendix F - Groundwater impact assessment 1 of 2
Appendix F - Groundwater impact assessment 2 of 2
Appendix G1 - Managed release study _Bohena Creek_
Appendix G2 - Concept irrigation design
Appendix G3 - Water monitoring plan
Appendix G4 - Water baseline report
Appendix H - Hydrology and geomorphology
Appendix I1 - Interpretive soils report
Appendix I2 - BSAL certificate
Appendix I3 - Contaminated land assessment
Appendix J1 - Ecological impact assessment 1 of 2
Appendix J1 - Ecological impact assessment 2 of 2
Appendix J2 - Biodiversity assessment report
Appendix K - Agricultural impact assessment
Appendix L - Air quality impact assessment
Appendix M - Noise and vibration assessment
Appendix N1 - Aboriginal cultural heritage assessment
Appendix N2 - Cultural heritage management plan
Appendix O - Historic heritage impact assessment
Appendix P - Traffic impact assessment
Appendix Q - Landscape and visual impact assessment
Appendix R - Greenhouse gas assessment
Appendix S - Hazard and risk assessment
Appendix T1 - Social impact assessment
Appendix T2 - Health impact assessment
Appendix T3 - Chemical risk assessment
Appendix U1 - Economic assessment cost benefit analysis
Appendix U2 - Economic assessment macroeconomic analysis
Appendix V - Rehabilitation strategy
Appendix W - Decommissioning report

Submissions (221)

Individual Group 1-9
Individual Group 1-59
Individual Group 1-179
Form letter type 1 - Sample
Form letter - 1A 0001-0100
Form letter - 1A 0101-0150
Form letter - 1A 0151-0200
Form letter - 1A 0201-0250
Form letter - 1A 0251-0300
Form letter - 1A 0301-0500
Form letter - 1A 0501-1000
Form letter - 1A 1001-2000
Form letter - 1A 2001-3000
Form letter - 1A 3001-4000
Form letter - 1A 4001-5000
Form letter - 1A 5001-5365
Form letter - 1B 0001-0600
Form letter - 1B 0601-0750
Form letter - 1B 0751-0800
Form letter - 1B 0801-0851
Form letter - 1B 0851-0900
Form letter - 1B 0901-1204
Form letter type 2 - Sample
Form letter - 2A 0001-0150
Form letter - 2A 0151-0225
Form letter - 2A 0226-0300
Form letter - 2A 0301-0450
Form letter - 2A 0451-0600
Form letter - 2A 0601-0750
Form letter - 2A 0751-0900
Form letter - 2A 0901-1050
Form letter - 2A 1050-1200
Form letter - 2A 1201-1350
Form letter - 2A 1351-1500
Form letter - 2A 1501-1650
Form letter - 2A 1651-1800
Form letter - 2A 1801-1950
Form letter - 2A 1951-2100
Form letter - 2A 2101-2250
Form letter - 2A 2251-2400
Form letter - 2A 2401-2550
Form letter - 2A 2551-2700
Form letter - 2A 2701-2850
Form letter - 2A 2851-3000
Form letter - 2A 3001-3150
Form letter - 2A 3151-3300
Form letter - 2A 3301-3450
Form letter - 2A 3451-3600
Form letter - 2A 3601-3750
Form letter - 2A 3751-3900
Form letter - 2A 3901-4050
Form letter - 2A 4051-4200
Form letter - 2A 4201-4349
Form letter - 2B 0001-0150
Form letter - 2B 0151-0300
Form letter - 2B 0301-0450
Form letter - 2B 0451-0600
Form letter - 2B 0601-0750
Form letter - 2B 0751-0900
Form letter - 2B 0901-1050
Form letter - 2B 1051-1200
Form letter - 2B 1201-1350
Form letter - 2B 1351-1500
Form letter - 2B 1501-1650
Form letter - 2B 1651-1731
Form letter - 2C Anonymous
Form letter - 2D Anonymous
Form letter type 3 - Sample
Form letter - 3A 0001-0100
Form letter - 3A 0101-0200
Form letter - 3A 0201-0300
Form letter - 3A 0301-0400
Form letter - 3A 0401-0500
Form letter - 3A 0501-0600
Form letter - 3A 0601-0700
Form letter - 3A 0701-0800
Form letter - 3A 0801-0900
Form letter - 3A 0901-1000
Form letter - 3A 1001-1100
Form letter - 3A 1101-1200
Form letter - 3A 1201-1300
Form letter - 3A 1301-1400
Form letter - 3A 1401-1500
Form letter - 3A 1501-1600
Form letter - 3A 1601-1700
Form letter - 3A 1701-1800
Form letter - 3A 1801-1900
Form letter - 3A 1901-2000
Form letter - 3A 2001-2100
Form letter - 3A 2101-2200
Form letter - 3A 2201-2300
Form letter - 3A 2301-2400
Form letter - 3A 2401-2500
Form letter - 3A 2501-2600
Form letter - 3A 2601-2700
Form letter - 3A 2701-2800
Form letter - 3A 2801-2900
Form letter - 3A 2901-3000
Form letter - 3A 3001-3100
Form letter - 3A 3101-3200
Form letter - 3A 3201-3288
Form letter - 3B 1-152
Form letter - 3D 1-123
Form letter - 3E 1-21
Form letter - 4A 1-50
Form letter - 5A 1-68
Form Letter - 6A 1-107
Form Letter - 6B 1-22
Form Letter - 6C Anonymous
Form Letter - 6D Anonymous
Form Letter - 7A 1-7
Form Letter - 7B 1-3
Form Letter - 7C Anonymous
Form Letter - 8A 1-11
Form Letter - 8C Anonymous
Special Interest Group: Armidale Action on Coal Seam Gas and Mining
Special Interest Group: Artesian Bore Water Users Association Inc - Supplementary R
Special Interest Group: Artesian Bore Water Users Association Inc-1
Special Interest Group: Artesian Bore Water Users Association Inc-2
Special Interest Group: Australian Air Quality Group
Special Interest Group: Australian Beef Group
Special Interest Group: Australian Plants Society Northern Beaches
Special Interest Group: Bayside Climate Change Action Group
Special Interest Group: Birding NSW
Special Interest Group: BirdLife Australia
Special Interest Group: Birdlife Northern NSW
Special Interest Group: Blacktown and District Environment Group
Special Interest Group: Blue Mountains Bird Observers
Special Interest Group: Clarence Environment Centre Inc
Special Interest Group: Clarence Valley Atronomical Society
Special Interest Group: Clarence Valley Conservation Coalition Inc
Special Interest Group: Climate Change Action Network_NarrabriProject
Special Interest Group: Climate Rights Newcastle and Hunter
Special Interest Group: Coal and CSG Free Mirboo North
Special Interest Group: Collectif Causse Mejean_ Gaz de Schiste NON !
Special Interest Group: Concerned Communities of Falkirk
Special Interest Group: Coonabarabran Residents Against CSG
Special Interest Group: Cotton Australia
Special Interest Group: Country Womens Association- NSW
Special Interest Group: Country Women's Association of NSW-Maules Creek
Special Interest Group: CountryMinded
Special Interest Group: CSG Free Shoalhaven
Special Interest Group: Cumberland Bird Observers Club
Special Interest Group: Dharriwaa Elders Group
Special Interest Group: Doctors for the Environment Australia
Special Interest Group: Dubbo Field Naturalist and Conservation Society Inc
Special Interest Group: ECCO
Special Interest Group: Evans Head Residents for Sustainable Development
Special Interest Group: Farmers for Climate Action
Special Interest Group: Friends of Siding Spring Observatory
Special Interest Group: Friends of the Earth Sydney
Special Interest Group: Friends of the Koalas
Special Interest Group: Friends of the Pilliga
Special Interest Group: GasFieldFreeDubboRegion
Special Interest Group: Gomeroi Traditional Custodians
Special Interest Group: Gomeroi Traditional Custodians Attachment
Special Interest Group: Great Artesian Basin Protection Group
Special Interest Group: Great Artesian Basin Protection Group-1
Special Interest Group: Greens_ Armidale Tamworth
Special Interest Group: Greens_ Hornsby Ku-ring-gai
Special Interest Group: Greens_ New England
Special Interest Group: Greens_ Northern Beaches
Special Interest Group: Groundswell Gloucester Inc.
Special Interest Group: Hastings Birdwatchers
Special Interest Group: IEEFA_ Narrabri Gas Project_ 21 May 2017
Special Interest Group: Kalang Progress Association_Narrabri Gas Project
Special Interest Group: Knitting Nanas_ Dubbo
Special Interest Group: Knitting Nanas_ Gloucester
Special Interest Group: Knitting Nanas_ Grafton
Special Interest Group: Knitting Nanas_ NENW
Special Interest Group: Koala Action Inc_Narrabri Gas Project
Special Interest Group: Kyogle Group Against Gas
Special Interest Group: Lismore Community Sustainability Forum
Special Interest Group: Lismore Environment Centre
Special Interest Group: Lock the Gate Alliance
Special Interest Group: Maules Creek Community Council _ Narrabri Submission FINAL
Special Interest Group: Mulgoa Valley Landcare Group
Special Interest Group: Mullaley Gas and Pipeline Accord Inc
Special Interest Group: Namoi Water
Special Interest Group: Narrabri and District Chamber of Commerce
Special Interest Group: Narrabri Cycle and Triathlon Club
Special Interest Group: Narrabri Local Aboriginal Land Council
Special Interest Group: National Parks Association NSW_ Armidale
Special Interest Group: National Parks Association NSW_ Southern Sydney Branch
Special Interest Group: National Toxics Network UG Sub Santos EIS April 2017
Special Interest Group: Nature Conservation Council of NSW
Special Interest Group: No CSG Gilgandra District Inc.
Special Interest Group: North Coast Environmental Council
Special Interest Group: North West Alliance Appendix I Kuskie Aboriginal Cultural H
Special Interest Group: North West Alliance
Special Interest Group: North West Plains Sustainability Group
Special Interest Group: Northern Inland Council for the Environment
Special Interest Group: NSW Bush Carers
Special Interest Group: NSW Business Chamber
Special Interest Group: NSW Nurses and Midwives' Association
Special Interest Group: Orange and Region Water Security Alliance
Special Interest Group: People for the Plains
Special Interest Group: Pets and Wildlife of Pottsville Beach
Special Interest Group: Protect Our Water Energy and Rights _POWER_
Special Interest Group: Regional Development Australia - Northern Inland NSW
Special Interest Group: Regional Development Australia - NSW
Special Interest Group: Residents for Environment and Character Conservation _RECC_
Special Interest Group: Rivers SOS
Special Interest Group: Running Stream Water Users Association
Special Interest Group: Ryde Gladesville Climate Change Action Group
Special Interest Group: Ryde Hunters Hill Flora and Fauna Preservation Society
Special Interest Group: Securing Australias Future For Our Kids _SAFFOK_
Special Interest Group: SOS Liverpool Plains_ Narrabri submission
Special Interest Group: Stop Coal Seam Gas_ Blue Mountains
Special Interest Group: Stop CSG Sydney Inc
Special Interest Group: Sustainable Living Armidale
Special Interest Group: The Colong Foundation for Wilderness Ltd
Special Interest Group: The Mullum Trust_Narrabri Gas Project
Special Interest Group: The Norwood Resource
Special Interest Group: The Wilderness Society
Special Interest Group: Think Brick Australia
Special Interest Group: Upper Mooki Landcare Attachment 4
Special Interest Group: Upper Mooki Landcare Inc
Special Interest Group: Wando Conservation and Cultural Centre
Special Interest Group: Yarrie Lake Flora and Fauna Trust
Special Interest Group: Yes2Gas

Response to Submissions (18)

Request for Response to Submissions
Response to Submissions
Appendix A-D
Appendix E-H
Appendix I-L
Supplementary Response to Sub
NW Alliance - Assoc Prof Hose - GDEs
NW Alliance - Australia Institute - Economic
NW Alliance - Dr Currell - Groundwater
NW Alliance - Dr Lawrence & Zillar - Social
NW Alliance - Dr Saddler - Greenhouse Gas
NW Alliance - Mr Hayley - Groundwater
NW Alliance - Mr Kuskie - Cultural Heritage
NW Alliance - Mr Milledge - Biodiversity
NW Alliance - Mr Paull - Terrestrial Ecology
NW Alliance - Ms Broughton - Groundwater
NW Alliance - Prof Khan - Produced Water
Upper Mooki Landcare - Mr Paull - Ecological

Agency Advice (46)

DPIE - BCD - Advice on EIS
DPIE - BCD - Advice on RTS
DPIE - BCD - Advice on Supplementary RTS
DPIE - BCD - Advice on MNES
DPIE - BCD - Advice on MNES - National Plans
DPIE - Water - Advice on EIS
DPIE - Water - Advice on RTS
DPIE - Water - Advice on Supplementary RTS
DPIE - Water - Advice on Conditions
DPIE - Water - Final Advice
EPA - Advice on EIS
EPA - Advice on RTS
EPA - Advice on Supplementary RTS
EPA - Final Advice
EPA - Final Advice on Fugitive Emissions
Regional NSW - MEG - Advice on EIS
Regional NSW - MEG - Advice on RTS
Regional NSW - MEG - Advice on Supplementary RTS
Regional NSW - Resources Regulator - Advice on RTS
Regional NSW - FCNSW - Advice on EIS
Regional NSW - FCNSW - Advice on RTS
Regional NSW - FCNSW - Final Advice
Regional NSW - NWLLS - Advice on EIS
DPC - Heritage Council of NSW - Advice on EIS
DPC - Heritage Council of NSW - Advice on RTS
TfNSW - Advice on EIS
TfNSW - Advice on RTS
TfNSW - Advice on Supplementary RTS
TfNSW (RMS) - Advice on EIS
TfNSW (RMS) - Advice on RTS
TfNSW (RMS) - Advice on Supplementary RTS
NSW Health - Advice on EIS
NSW Health - Advice on RTS
RFS - Advice on EIS
RFS - Advice on RTS
RFS - Advice on Supplementary RTS
Council - Narrabri Council - Advice on EIS
Council - Narrabri Council - Advice on RTS
Council - Narrabri Council - Advice on Supp RTS
Council - Narrabri Shire Council - Final Advice
Council - Gunnedah Shire Council - Advice on EIS
Council - Warrumbungle Council - Advice on EIS
Council - Gilgandra Shire Council - Advice on EIS
Commonwealth - Aus Observatory - Advice on EIS
Commonwealth - Aus Observatory - Advice on RTS
Commonwealth - ARTC - Advice on EIS

Additional Information (8)

Appx E1 - Leewood Central Gas Processing Facility
Appx E2 - Leewood QRA Assumption Register
Appx E3 - Air Quality Impact Assessment Supplementary Report
Appx E4 - Response to RFS Issues
Appx E5 - Bushfire Ignition Frequency
Appx E6 - Operation of the Leewood Safety Flare
Appx E7 - Strategic Context Update
Appx E8 - Response to Narrabri Council

Assessment (8)

Department's Assessment Report
Appendix H1 - Hazards and Risks Expert Advice
Appendix H2 - A - Economics Expert Advice
Appendix H2 - B - Economics Expert Advice Appendix
Appendix H3 - Aboriginal Heritage Expert Advice
Appendix H4 - A - Social Impact Expert Advice
Appendix H4 - B - Social Impact Expert Advice
Recommended Conditions

Determination (3)

Notice of Determination
SSD 6456 Statement of Reasons
SSD 6456 Development Consent

Approved Documents

Management Plans and Strategies (31)

Biodiversity Management Plan Expert Approval
Field Development Plan
Staging Approval
Aboriginal Cultural Heritage MP Approval
Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Managent Plan
Waste Management Plan
Waste Management Plan Approval
Rehabilitation Management Plan Approval
Rehabilitation Management Plan
DPE_Santos Narrabri RMP_RR satisfactory
Field Development Protocol Approval
Staging Request Letter
Field Development Protocol
Environmental Management Strategy Approval
Dust Suppression Protocol
Environmental Management Strategy
Erosion and Sediment Control Plan
Irrigation Management Plan
Historic Heritage Management Plan Approval
Noise Management Plan
Site Water Balance
Historic Heritage Management Plan
Produced Salt Beneficial Reuse and Disposal Approv
Surface Water Management Plan
Produced Water Management Plan
Produced Salt Beneficial Reuse and Disposal Study
Water Management Plan Approval
Water Management Plan
Biodiversity Management Plan Approval
Biodiversity Management Plan
Groundwater Management Plan

Reports (1)

2021 Annual Review

Other Documents (1)

Other_03022021_090112

Note: Only documents approved by the Department after November 2019 will be published above. Any documents approved before this time can be viewed on the Applicant's website.

Complaints

Want to lodge a compliance complaint about this project?

Make a Complaint

Enforcements

There are no enforcements for this project.

Inspections

There are no inspections for this project.

Note: Only enforcements and inspections undertaken by the Department from March 2020 will be shown above.

Submissions

Filters
Showing 1 - 20 of 6108 submissions
Name Withheld
Support
Sutton Forest , New South Wales
Message
The Narrabri Gas Project will create a local development which will generate jobs and investment in the local region. This will benefit local families, businesses and organizations by investing in local supplies and services. Santos has a good relationship with many of its stakeholders in the community and I have witnessed first hand the community support for the project. This is a result of Santos' successful integration into the local community and its enduring spirit in ensuring the project is not only a success for the company, but also the many stakeholders such as job seekers, businesses and local and state economies. I have every confidence in the studies which have been undertaken and that the impacts as a result of this development will be mitigated as best as possible. I support the Narrabri Gas Project and look forward to its contribution to the state of NSW.
Sarah Pickette
Object
Bangor , New South Wales
Message
I grew up near the Pilliga and my parents live on the edge of the Pilliga forest today. Anyone familiar with the Pilliga can tell you it is a very special part of Australia's wilderness. I strongly object to the extraction of coal-seam gas in the Pilliga for many reasons. I don't believe Santos has any right to financially benefit from a resource that belongs to all of us. My main objection though is an error in the EIS that gives the bushfire risk of Santos's proposed extraction sites as 'medium'. As someone very familiar with the landscape and terrain of the Pilliga I maintain that the bushfire risk of any coal-seam gas activity in the Pilliga should be assessed as high to truthfully represent the danger to property and, far more importantly, human life. An adequate risk assessment has not been completed.
Robert Shield
Object
Stanmore , New South Wales
Message
I ask that Santos Application be rejected on the following grounds.
The gas is not required for domestic use. The gas extracted will be transported and sold overseas. There is sufficient gas available for domestic use.
The project will damage the environment. The Pilliga is a valuable area which supports a diverse range of wildlife. It should be preserved not mined. CSG extraction has been seen to damage the local environment by leakage of extraction chemicals including salts, and fugitive gas emissions.
There are insufficient guarantees in place that the mine will clean up its mess at the completion of the project.
Global Warming. Australia should pursue and invest in low emissions energy generation, not one which will generate greenhouse gases.
Michael Kirby White
Object
Ashfield , New South Wales
Message
To whom it may concern,

My name is Michael Kirby White and I wish to express my concerns about the Narrabri Gas Project (NGP), and recommend that it not be approved.

Coal Seam Gas (CSG) is not a safe form of gas extraction. The methods used to extract the gas from the ground are associated with the pollution of ground and surface water as a result of chemicals being injected into gas wells. This ultimately harms the ecosystems and risks the viability of those farmlands that rely on these water supplies for their survival. Furthermore, CSG is associated with methane emissions that will contribute to global warming and create an obstacle to Australia meeting the targets it agreed to as part of the Paris Climate Agreement.

Santos have argued in their Environmental Impact Statement that the NGP will potentially create new jobs for the community. However, we need to take note of the negative effect that the NGP will have of employment on a wider specturm. For example, the potential for job losses in the agriculture sector when water sources become contaminated. Alternatively, regional communities may see movements of people out of the region as they seek accommodation and employment in areas not effected by water pollution.

Finally, the NGP should not progress as the New South Wales community should be moving to a future based on renewable energy sources. All decisions on our energy future should strongly consider the need to invest in alternative renewable energy projects and consider the negative effects that any project will have on creating the market mechanisms required for renewable energy projects to succeed.

Thank you for your consideration of my concerns.

Kind regards,

Michael Kirby White
Robert Davies
Object
Boonah , Queensland
Message
The Piliga forest is unique and must be protected from CSG development. The aquifer below is vital to our farming and must not be contaminated. We need to transition away from fossil fuels if we are to reverse the devastating effects of increased carbon in our atmosphere. I am totally opposed to the proposal by Santos to install 850 gas wells in the Piliga Forest.
Gordon Grant
Object
Tahmoor , New South Wales
Message
Having kept track of this project for some time I don't believe that there are adequate safety measures, nor adequate consideration of environmental issues. The very real risks far outweigh any assumed benefits. This sort of project only has one chance to get it right and many, many ways it can go wrong.

I oppose the project.
CJ Eddy
Object
Wooloweyah , New South Wales
Message
In view of Santos' existing record of pollution (including a creek) in the Pilliga forest, the wanton and terrible destruction already inflicted upon the native fauna, and the fact that NSW already has a steady supply of gas, it is obvious that if Santos goes ahead with this project it will be for export, and the possibility of further price increases for our Australian usage.
The impact on the environment makes no sense at all. In view of Santos financial position it is doubtful the NSW govt is ever going to see much revenue and once the project is up and running the employment for the region drops significantly (as shown in places like Chinchilla and Tara Qld) and towns are left with the mess and no one to clean it up.
This project should never see the light of day and over 80pc of northern and regional areas have already opposed this poisonous industry for reasons which can already been seen in Qld.
Lachlan Barker
Object
Byron Bay , New South Wales
Message
I say a flat out NO to Santos's Narrabri gas project.
Santos claim that the gas from this project will be for use in NSW industry and home, nothing could be further from the truth.
Santos are currently going bankrupt, with their debt maturing in 2019.
In the run up to that they are frantically trying to reduce their debt load, which stood at US$4.3 billion in November 2016.
Their LNG plant at Gladstone is loss making at current oil prices, and will continue to be so with no rise in oil prices ever likely to happen again, with the rise of electric vehicles, and the instability of the OPEC production cut deal.
Thus Santos's only plan is to sell "assets" so they can reduce this debt.
The Narrabri project is one of these, and the only reason they put in the EIS is so they can get it approved, so they can then sell it.
NSW will never see any gas out of Narrabri.
What's more, if this project is approved, and then sold, and against all economic sense the 850 wells are drilled, that would cost approximately A$3 billion, which Santos, nor any other gas player, has available to invest in a dud project.
And clearly, the pilot wells already drilled and infrastructure built at Narrabri have caused considerable damage.
Rather than approving this economic and environmentally destructive violation, the state government need to cancel it now, and order Santos to clean up the mess they have already made.
There is gas aplenty in Bass Strait which will provide NSW with all the gas it needs, and cheaply at that, in perpetuity, so the only logical step is for the NSW state government to cancel the Narrabri CSG project now.
This is what the voters of NSW want, so think on that Gladys Berejiklian.
David Fenton
Object
Wongawallan , Queensland
Message
I agree with the Maules Creek branch of the NSW Country Womens Association which opposes unconventional gas because the results of hosting unconventional gas are:

PROPERTIES DEVALUED,
MORTGAGES REFUSED,
INSURANCE COVERS REJECTED,
FAMILIES DESTROYED,
COMMUNITIES DIVIDED,
AQUIFERS DRAINED,
LAND POISONED,
CHILDREN SICKENED,
MENTAL BREAKDOWNS
AND SUICIDE.

If this project progresses it will:

- be against the assessment of a foundational core of Australian Society.
- be an assault, violating elements foundational to a healthy society.
and, its natural for such assaults to be opposed by strenuous and primal responses.

Truth speaks for itself, those that walk with the smooth ways of common sense, listening to and heeding nature's ways, are supported by the very nature of things. But those that walk in opposition, are opposed.

As a scientist with the training to make environmental impact assessments I could have referred to research, investigations and evidence but what is needed in this instance is basic honesty because the facts are plain from others experience. Honest decent people look at the reality then act wisely and fairly ... unfortunately CSG to asks people to turn a blind eye, act foolishly and with gross unfairness towards others.

Note:
I am familiar with people at Qld who have been effected by unconventional gas mining as mentioned by the CWA branch.
This includes suicide (Mr Bender, I have conversed with his daughter Helen via internet)
Sick children (The daughters of Sandi Bamberry, I have met these wonderful people and have seen in their experience the detrimental health and financial effects of unconventional gas)
Depression and stress (People like the Benders and Bamberries) .
Financial restrictions in the areas of land value and loans.

Having been touched by people effected so detrimentally by unconventional gas mining, including CSG mining ... In my view to go ahead with it is to invite the same upon the heads of good NSW folk ... and in the light of such experience, it will be negligent.

Sincerely

David John Fenton

BSc (AES, Env Pollution and Health), Dip Ed,
Name Withheld
Support
Bowral , New South Wales
Message
I value my privacy. This submission is provided on the basis that my name and address details remain confidential.

I have read the executive summary and sections of the Narrabri gas project EIS. I am also familiar with the content of the earlier Site Verification Certificate application.

I support this project wholeheartedly.

NEED FOR THE PROJECT:

This is an essential project for NSW.

NSW has gone through a period of approvals paralysis for gas exploration and production drilling. This has seen gas prices increase by about 15% in 2014-2015 alone, placing significant stress on household budgets, and pressure on industrial users.
(source: https://industry.gov.au/Energy/Energy-information/Documents/Gas-Price-Trends-Report.pdf)

The only alternative sources of gas for NSW come from Victoria. Relying on Victoria to supply gas is the very definition of insanity, when Victoria has declared a moratorium on all gas exploration drilling until 2020 and a ban on hydraulic fracture stimulation.

Furthermore, all of the jobs and economic growth in NSW in the past 5 years has been focused on Sydney, and driven by Sydney house prices and infrastructure projects, with regional areas actually experiencing economic contraction of 0.3% p.a. This is a deplorable situation which is resulting in perverse outcomes, and the NSW government should be urgently addressing this imbalance.
(source: http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/a-state-divided-parts-of-nsw-recessionhit-as-sydney-booms-20161129-gszvwz.html)

As an example of one of the perverse outcomes of this economic imbalance, my local area was recently identified as having the seventh most unaffordable housing in the world, when measured against wages. As a homeowner I have made far more money (on paper) in the last three years from owning a home (a non-productive asset) than from working. This is not actually a good thing, because if I move house most of my costs are a percentage of the house price - such as stamp duty and real estate fees - so the only winners here are the NSW government. I have also seen my suburb gradually change from being filled with young families (affordable homes) to wealthy retirees from Sydney paying over a million dollars in some cases. The average wage in my area is $43,900. Clearly this level of earnings can not support a million dollar mortgage.

(sources: http://www.southernhighlandnews.com.au/story/4424099/wingecarribee-in-top-10-least-affordable-cities/

http://stat.abs.gov.au/itt/r.jsp?RegionSummary&region=11402&dataset=ABS_REGIONAL_ASGS&geoconcept=REGION&measure=MEASURE&datasetASGS=ABS_REGIONAL_ASGS&datasetLGA=ABS_REGIONAL_LGA&regionLGA=REGION&regionASGS=REGION)

The Narrabri gas project will provide a long-term supply of gas for NSW, helping to keep gas prices affordable, and even more fundamentally, just "keep the lights on". It will also result in jobs for a regional area, helping to address the imbalance between Sydney and regional NSW. Economically vibrant regions are part of the key to keeping the pressures off Sydney and surrounds.

THE ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT
The environmental assessment found that the project will not impact on any strategic agricultural land (BSAL).

Furthermore, the project will not result in any cumulative impacts.

The volume of groundwater to be extracted is well within the sustainable yield of the groundwater system, and will generate many orders of magnitude the economic benefits that the same volume of water could generate if it was put to agriculture. The project will put the produced water to beneficial use where possible.

Finally, the assessment found that the project is consistent with the findings of the NSW Chief Scientist and Engineer's 2014 report on coal seam gas.

There can be no excuse to refuse this project. It is essential to the economic welfare and energy security of NSW.

If any activist groups or individuals oppose this project on purely ideological grounds without having properly reviewed the EIS, the NSW government should politely require them to give up their electricity, iphones, cars, modern medical care, food produced using modern agricultural techniques, steel, glass and concrete, medicines, welfare payments and other benefits of modern life that are provided by widely available and affordable energy.






Name Withheld
Support
KEIRAVILLE , New South Wales
Message
It is my understanding that recently the Victorian Govt declared a moratorium on gas exploration and production drilling till 2020. A ban has also been placed on hydraulic fracture stimulation.
At the moment we in NSW can rely on the Cooper Basin in South Australia but when that runs out then our only alternative gas supplier would be Victoria - and with the moratorium and ban described above I do not see how we can leave the fate of the NSW economy in the hands of the Victorian government.

This project will provide 500 employment places during the life of the project - thus securing some hope for work in the future for our children and grandchildren and importantly, the project will not disturb prime agricultural land;
also it will not pollute any surface or groundwater
Name Withheld
Object
South Melbourne , Victoria
Message
Allowing this project to go ahead will contribute to the ever growing inter-generational equity failings of current energy and land use practices. The economy and social landscape of modern Australia is ready for a complete shift towards renewable energy sources. This project will not only fly in the face of the ever increasing request from Australian society to move to renewable energy, but will also contribute to increases in carbon emissions and reduction in ecological integrity of some of Australia's most untouched environments. On the above basis, I strongly oppose this development and as a tax payer and citizen request that the government (as my employer) does not proceed.
Name Withheld
Object
Werribee , Victoria
Message
I think it's highly inappropriate for Santos to be drilling for coal seam gas in the Pilliga which is a significant area for all Australians not just the locals.
The local community of Pilliga do not want it and nor do I. I hope you will hear our objections and choose a location that does not impact the environment or its people.
Thankyou.
Rachel Hudman
Object
Dianella , Western Australia
Message
This will be devastating to the regional eco systems and in the long term the entire earth . I believe it if our responsibility to protect Australia for the the future , not just make the rich richer.
Susan Aldhous
Object
Macclesfield , South Australia
Message
I am writing this submission to strongly put my outrage on the plan that Santos has to drill 850 wells in the Pilliga region. The danger to this natural environment and the Artesian basin is far too great. In these days of water shortages the idea of putting this inter-connected water system under any threat, no matter how small seems to me inconceivable. Once 850 wells are operating the landscape and habitat will be broken up, we have already learnt that this can have disastrous effects on native wildlife.
Name Withheld
Object
Stockleigh , Queensland
Message
I object to the destruction of the forests in the Great Artesian Basin. These areas are of great ecological, environmental and historical significance and should not fall victim to coal seam gas.
Aaron Job
Object
Kangroo Flat , Victoria
Message
To whom it may concern,

I respectfully object to this project. There are many reasons for this, ranging from threatening wildlife to climate change concerns, but my main objection is around the threat to the Great Australian Basin.

Why it is even conceivable that a freshwater source (of which we have so few in the country) be put under threat, the only environmental restriction that can guarantee it is safe from contamination and damage is just not to build the wells. This could have implications to so many who rely on the water in the basin, I simply think it is a terrible idea.

Thank you for your time in reading my submission

Aaron Job
Clare Millen
Object
Brunswick , Victoria
Message
There is no amount of money in the world that justifies risking any ground water health, particularly that of the Artesian basin. Even low risk is some risk and is not worth it to make some quick profits for a company with an extremely unethical reputation and history of environmental damage. Please do the only right thing by our people, our environment and future generations and do not allow CGS projects to destroy our fragile environment. There is not need for CSG when there are much better and safer energy alternatives out there.
jasmine freeman
Object
Wendoree Park , New South Wales
Message
No way this should go ahead - the damage caused by drilling for gas is irreparable.
Patricia Riley
Object
Pakenham , Victoria
Message
I do not support any government legislation that allows for the coal seam gas projects to go ahead. This is destroying our eco system. We need to invest in renewable's and create jobs via renewable's. We cannot let our governments short term profit and lies destroy our beloved country

Pagination

Project Details

Application Number
SSD-6456
EPBC ID Number
2014/7376
Assessment Type
State Significant Development
Development Type
Petroleum Extraction
Local Government Areas
Narrabri Shire
Decision
Approved
Determination Date
Decider
IPC-N

Contact Planner

Name
Rose-Anne Hawkeswood